We listen, vainly, as the work proceeds, for the semblance of a melody. 7 The Musical World, March 7, 1846, p. 105.Įrnani led us to suspect, and Nabucco has certified our suspicion, that of all the modern Italian composers Verdi is the most thoroughly insignificant.Verdi is bizarre with a vengeance: under the idea of contrast or climax, of dramatic force and passion -but his science is “to seek”-with his melody -and unless he take the field under some new form, we cannot believe that his popularity will long survive the discovery of the recipe by which his dash is concocted. The vocal composer who writes noisy orchestral parts in unison with his singers-who utterly disdain the keeping which allots one order of support and decoration to a solo, and another to an assemblage of voices, is bound to show good cause for the reversal of every known principle of common sense, and the sacrifice of every effect. etc.-nay there is a flagrant disregard of science in his music. Verdi’s noisy mixtures of ophicleides, piccoli, harps, etc. There is more science in one of Haydn’s minuets to his early quartets, than in all Sig.
Even the enthusiasts confess them to be meagre in melody-to contain no solitary indication of a new form or manner of air, such as gives an individuality to Bellini and Donizetti,-while, to praise their science on the glaring orchestral touches, is to insult the capacities of those who know the meaning of language. Nor has the rage for his compositions, since excited in Italy, shaken us. Verdi’s music, we have never seen cause to change the judgment of his claims as a composer then expressed.
Signor Verdi’s forte is declamatory music of the highest passion.
On the other hand, not all the critics had a high opinion of the artistic value of Verdi’s new operas while Chorley from The Athenaeum and Davison from The Musical World wrote of Verdi’s works in hostile terms, The Times and The Illustrated London News showed signs of sincere appreciation. In a popular sense the opera, conducted by Michael Balfe and interpreted by Luciano Fornasari as Nino, Giulia Sanchioli as Abigail and Amalia Corbari as Fenena, was a success.
#1846 verdi opera free
The same religious subject which would be banned as a drama was free to be presented in its “musical disguise.”ģ On the occasion of Nino ’s premiere, both the general public and the critics seemed to divide into two opposing camps: while the first was always keen on novelty, the second tended to reject it entirely in the name of so-called classicism. Since the vast majority of the public did not really understand the lyrics, which were, to some extent, considered complementary to the music, a few changes in the plot and its transposition to a safer historical setting would suffice.
#1846 verdi opera license
The change in the title and the plot conformed to this norm, although it was applied with a certain degree of flexibility in fact “it was possible for religious plays to be granted the Lord Chamberlain’s license as long as the directness of the scriptural parallels was obscured sufficiently to satisfy the letter rather than the spirit of the prohibition on scriptural drama.” 2 The ban was generally mitigated in so far as an operatic performance in Italian was involved.
0 kommentar(er)
